Book It In - Book ReviewsReviews

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell: A Review

Book It In

What on Earth is this novel?

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell is Susanna Clarke’s bestselling Fantasy History Novel. And it is amazing, astounding, supertastical, and brilliant. These are all just a handful of the real (and created) adjectives possible to throw at this tome. Were one to enter into an adjective war this book would defeat them hands down. For the potency of the words inside is incredible. And having done so would commence to bury  in a pile of prose so powerful that I would be diabolically destroyed.

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell is a hauntingly beautiful book. It was well written with the careful and clear strokes of a master artist. A woman who clearly loves words and language and with abounding wit. An author who believed in her world with passion. She wasn’t simply writing but creating a world with such clarity.


Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell focuses on two magicians in the early 1800s as they attempt to bring back the practice of English magic. Introduce fairies, madness and the intricacies of magic and you’re not even half way to begin understanding the intricacies of the plot. In fact it is doubtful anyone can sum up the plot in several words. Not the way that Susanna Clarke writes it.

The real power of this novel is in how Susanna Clarke analyses the two protagonists. Most novels only build half a perspective of who the characters are. In this work the author builds a complex and detailed perspective of who all her characters are. While the two magicians are the most fleshed out, so that the reader may observe their flaws and strengths, even secondary characters are exposed as human beings. These are not half hearted portrayals but rather creations of words designed to show depth and meaning.

But it is not simply the characters that reveal depth and intrigue. The world Susanna Clarke imagines is so vividly described that it feels a part of history. In many ways this world is written so that it feels like an ancient true event is being described. The addition of Lord Byron and mention of Mr and Mrs Shelley add to such a tone. The value of an intelligent, resourceful writer who does her research is thus revealed.

Magical Weaknesses?

So what are the weaknesses of this book. Some would say the length, although the length allowed for such a development of world and characters. One could complain about the footnotes. But they were inciteful and added to the depth of the world. Providing details such as book titles, magical theories, tales of magic and magicians of the past expanded the book for me in a nice way. One may also pick faults with the use of shewing and chuse instead of showing and chose. But those obsolete words were used to help create the tone of 1800s England and their use grows upon the reader over time.

This is a magnificent book and if readers can get around the length, it is very much worth reading. Worth reading for all lovers of books. One could always ‘cheat’ and listen to the audio-book version instead. They do help heighten the experience of having read the book. However if one is a meticulous reader, or a quick reader it may be recommended to read another book at the same time. For this is hardly a page turner. But rather it is a book that must be slowly devoured like a fine dessert or beverage.

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke






Themes and Ideas


Unique elements



  • A magical unique storyline
  • Alternate history with fairies
  • Beautifully written


  • A very long novel
Like what you see? Let others know about our site!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.